Type 9 and holiday plans: how to say what you actually want
Many Type 9s answer holiday plans with 'I don't mind'. Here is how to find your real preference, say one small thing early, and what the research does and doesn't show.
Someone in the family chat asks where everyone wants to spend the holiday. Six people answer. Yours is "Whatever works for everyone!" and you mean it. Then the plan lands on the one version of the day you were quietly dreading.
If that sounds familiar, you may lean toward Type 9, the Harmonizer. Nines are often the easiest person in the room to be around, and that ease can hide what they would have picked. These are tendencies, not destinies. The rest of this article is about keeping the ease and adding one clear sentence.
Why is "I don't mind" the usual answer?
For many Nines, going along feels like kindness. You can feel what the group needs almost before anyone says it, and your own preference arrives later, softer, or not at all.
At the holidays this gets louder. Old family habits come back, and each person slides into the part they played years ago. If you want a closer look at that pull, see the old family role each type slips into.
The strength is real: you keep tempers down and make people feel welcome. The growth edge is that everyone else ends up planning around a blank. A "no preference" answer isn't neutral. It hands the decision to whoever speaks loudest.
How do you find what you want before you say it?
Sometimes the problem isn't saying it. You haven't found it yet. A few ways to look:
- Picture two versions of the day. One where you host, one where you travel. Notice which one lets your shoulders drop.
- Start smaller than "the plan". Which day you arrive. How long you stay. Where you sleep. Whether you need an hour alone after lunch.
- Check the dread. If one option makes your stomach tighten, that is information, even if you can't explain it yet.
| Vague answer | A specific version |
|---|---|
| "Whatever works." | "I'd like to be home by Sunday night." |
| "I'm fine with any of it." | "I'd rather skip the second dinner." |
| "You decide." | "I'm happy to host if someone else brings dessert." |
Small wants count. A preference about timing is still a preference.
Why say one small thing early?
Plans harden quickly. A request made before the dates are set is a suggestion. The same request made after the tickets are bought feels like a complaint.
Aim for one ask, in one sentence, before the plan is final. You don't have to defend it, and you don't need a speech. "I'd like to keep Saturday open" is enough.
Pick the want that matters most and leave the rest. Nines sometimes try to weigh everyone's feelings first and end up saying nothing at all. One honest sentence is better than a perfect one that never gets sent. For more on this kind of everyday wording, the communication guide has more to try.
Why does a ready phrase help?
Knowing you are allowed to say no is not the same as knowing how. In two lab experiments with university students (174 and 323 people), researchers found that giving people a specific phrase to decline, such as "I'd rather not", made them feel significantly freer to refuse than telling them they had the right to. The effect on whether people actually complied was small and not statistically significant, so it is a hint rather than proof it changes behavior.
The practical idea still holds: having the words ready lowers the awkwardness. Some phrases to borrow and reword:
- "I'd rather not do the long drive this year."
- "That doesn't work for me, but I'd like to find something that does."
- "I'm in for dinner, and I'll skip the afterparty."
Say one out loud before the call. It sounds odd the first time. The second time, less so.
How do you handle pushback?
Someone may sigh, or say "but you always come." That's normal, and it doesn't mean you were wrong to ask.
- Say it once more, calmly. Same words, same tone. You don't need new reasons.
- Offer something in return. "I can't do the long weekend, but I'd love to see you Friday."
- Let a short silence sit. Nines often fill it by giving in. You can wait.
If you want help with the guilt side, this piece on saying no to holiday plans without guilt covers every type.
If holiday stress has been hurting your sleep or your work for weeks, talk to a doctor or a licensed counselor. An article can't help with that.
What does the research say?
The Enneagram is a reflection tool with mixed research support, and the evidence on Type 9 specifically is thin. The studies below are about the behaviors, not about the type.
- Assertiveness can be learned. A study protocol describes it as communicating needs and thoughts clearly and directly while still listening to others, somewhere between passive and aggressive, and says it is a skill that can be learned or improved. Training programs use practice and role-play.
- People-pleasing has modest links to well-being. In a survey of 2,203 first-year university students in China, higher people-pleasing scores were modestly associated with lower well-being, along with more loneliness and social avoidance. The correlations were small, and this is one student sample.
- Type 9 evidence is limited. One network study of 859 students in Peru links the peaceful style to coping with hard social moments, but it is cross-sectional and self-reported, so it cannot show cause and effect. The link between Type 9 and healthy functioning under stress was weak.
Take it as a prompt for curiosity. Notice when you go quiet, then try a small ask. For a wider look at what helps under pressure, see stress patterns across types.
What to take from this
You don't have to get louder to say what you want. Find one small preference, say it early in one sentence, keep a phrase handy, and let a short pause do its work.
Not sure Type 9 is yours? Take the test to find your core type.
Frequently asked questions
Why do Type 9s say 'I don't mind' about holiday plans?
Often it comes from a real wish to keep things smooth, and sometimes it covers a preference you haven't noticed yet. Both can be true in the same conversation. Many Nines find it easier to sense what the group wants than what they want.
How can a Type 9 work out what they want before the family calls?
Picture two versions of the day and notice which one lets your shoulders drop. Then write down one thing from it, however small: which day you travel, how long you stay, where you sleep.
Is it selfish to ask for what you want at the holidays?
No. One clear, kind request gives other people something to work with. Guessing games cost everyone more, and the people who love you usually want to know.
Does research show that Type 9s avoid conflict more?
Not directly. The one study we found that looks at Type 9 is a cross-sectional survey of university students and cannot show cause and effect. Treat conflict avoidance as a common pattern people describe, not a proven rule.
Sources
- Giving people the words to say no leads them to feel freer to say yes
- The Mental Health Implications of People-Pleasing: Psychometric Properties and Latent Profiles of the Chinese People-Pleasing Questionnaire
- Imagine All the People: A Guided Internet-Based Imagery Training to Increase Assertiveness among University Students (study protocol)
- Enneagram typologies and healthy personality to psychosocial stress: A network approach