Skip to content

Year-end reviews at work: how to give feedback to each Enneagram type

No one has tested feedback by Enneagram type, but your own type can shape how you give and take a year-end review. Nine tendencies and habits that help everyone.

More on Leadership and work


How should you give year-end feedback to each Enneagram type?

Nobody has tested a type-by-type script for it, so be wary of anyone who sells one. What you can do is use your own type to notice how you give and take feedback, ask colleagues how they like to hear things, and keep the conversation about the work. The nine tendencies below are starting points for that, not labels to stick on people.

You may know the feeling. The invite for the year-end review lands in your calendar, and your stomach does something before your mind catches up. That reaction says a lot about how you may handle the other side of the table too.

Does feedback style really matter?

It does, though not always the way people hope. A review of feedback research summarizes the classic finding: feedback raised performance by about 0.4 standard deviations on average, yet about one third of the studies showed a negative effect. The same review notes that too many task-specific details can hurt when the task is already clear.

Personality seems to play a part, though the evidence is mostly not about the Enneagram. In an online study of 916 adults, people who scored high on conscientiousness and neuroticism kept working less after negative feedback on a frustrating task and more after negative feedback on a playful one. The task mattered as much as the person. The authors also used false, non-specific feedback, so treat the result as a hint rather than a rule.

Workplace evidence is still unsettled. A published plan for a review of 360-degree feedback calls the evidence on its effects contested and lists personality and a person's openness to feedback as things it will examine. It has no results yet.

The plain takeaway: how you deliver feedback and what the person is facing both matter. We found no study that tests different feedback for different Enneagram types.

Start with your own type

Before you think about anyone else, look at yourself. Most of us have a habit that shows up at review time. Maybe it's one of these:

  • You may over-correct, soften every point, or go quiet.
  • You may rush to the positives, or skip them.
  • You may take a critical comment as a verdict on you.

Pick the one that sounds most like you and write it down before the meeting. If you don't know your core type yet, take the test and come back. The communication guide is a good next read.

Nine tendencies: what each type may hear, and what tends to help

Read this table as a mirror first. If you recognize your own row, ask what it means for how you run the conversation. These are our reading of the type descriptions, not research findings.

TypeMay hear it asWhat often helps
1, the Principled"You are not good enough."Name what was done well in the same breath as the fix.
2, the Nurturer"You are not valued."Thank the effort, then ask what support they need.
3, the Driver"You are not a success."Be concrete about results and what comes next.
4, the Original"You are ordinary."Be honest and unhurried, and name what is distinctive.
5, the Scholar"You are not competent."Send points ahead of time and leave room to think.
6, the Steadfast"You can't be counted on."Be consistent and clear about what is expected.
7, the Optimist"You are boring or stuck."Stay brief and forward-looking, and agree one real follow-up.
8, the Powerhouse"You are being managed."Be direct and respect their pushback.
9, the Harmonizer"You are in the way."Ask for their view first and give them time to answer.

Here is a little more on each, as tendencies with a strength and a growth edge.

Type 1, the Principled. Ones often hold themselves to a high standard and may already be listing their own flaws before you speak. Their strength is care for quality. Their growth edge is hearing "good" without hunting for the catch. Start with what worked.

Type 2, the Nurturer. Twos tend to read feedback through the relationship. They are often generous with colleagues, and may bring their own list of everyone they helped. Ask what they need from the next year, not only what they gave.

Type 3, the Driver. Threes often focus on results and may want the headline fast. Their strength is momentum. Their growth edge is separating what they achieved from who they are. Give them specifics and a clear goal.

Type 4, the Original. Fours may feel a review as a test of whether they are seen. They often bring depth and honesty to work. Don't rush to fix their reaction. Say what they do that others don't, then name the one change you need.

Type 5, the Scholar. Fives may want time to process and can go quiet in the room. Their strength is careful thinking. Send the main points before the meeting and let them reply later if they want to.

Type 6, the Steadfast. Sixes often scan for what could go wrong, which can make them reliable. In a review, vague wording may sound like bad news. Be plain about what you are, and are not, worried about.

Type 7, the Optimist. Sevens may nod, move on and lose the hard part. Their strength is energy and ideas. Keep your point to one or two items, and agree one concrete step so it does not fade.

Type 8, the Powerhouse. Eights tend to value directness and may push back at once. That is often a sign of engagement, not defiance. Say it straight, stay steady, and let them have a say.

Type 9, the Harmonizer. Nines may agree to keep the peace and share their real view later, or not at all. Their strength is steadiness. Ask open questions and wait for the answer.

If you saw a familiar habit in your own row, the leadership guide has more on working with it.

What works for almost everyone?

A few habits do not depend on type.

  • Name the behavior, not the person. In a small randomized trial, specific, behavior-oriented feedback went with improvement, especially among lower performers. The authors call the result tentative, so take it as a good habit, not a promise.
  • Ask first. "How do you think the year went?" gives you their view and takes some heat out of the room.
  • Keep it to one or two priorities. Long lists blur. Choose what matters most.
  • End with a next step. Agree what happens next and when you will check in.

If you want to look at your own year too, our career guide covers how types tend to approach growth at work.

If you are the one getting the review

Notice your first reaction before you answer it. Then ask for one example you can act on, and give yourself a day before you reply to anything that stung. Our year-end reflection questions for each type can help you prepare, and type 6 and type 9 readers in particular may find the "ask for an example" step useful.

Where does the Enneagram stand?

The Enneagram is a reflection tool with mixed research support. A systematic review of the literature found mixed evidence on reliability and validity, and little research on wings and movement between types. Group-level findings also cannot tell you what one person will do.

So never use a type to judge, rank or label a colleague. A type can help you ask a better question. The answer has to come from the person.

Conclusion

Use your own type to see how you give and take feedback. Ask people how they like to hear it, and keep the review about the work. When the year closes, try a realistic New Year plan for each type to turn feedback into a few next steps.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use the Enneagram to rate my team's performance?

No. The Enneagram is a reflection tool with mixed research support, and it says nothing about how well someone did their job. Use it to think about how you deliver and receive feedback. Ratings should rest on the work people actually did.

What if I don't know my colleague's type?

You don't need to. Guessing someone's type from the outside is unreliable and can feel presumptuous. Ask them how they like to get feedback, and use the type descriptions on yourself.

Does one approach work for every type?

A few habits help almost everyone: name specific behaviors, ask for their view first, and agree on a next step. Type-based tweaks are small adjustments on top of those basics.

How do I handle my own reaction to a tough review?

Notice your usual first reaction, pause before answering, and ask for an example you can act on. Your type's tendencies are a starting point for noticing, not an excuse.

Sources

  1. Feedback review summarizing Kluger and DeNisi (Frontiers in Education, 2021)
  2. Improving the effectiveness of performance feedback by considering personality traits and task demands (PLoS One, 2018)
  3. Specific feedback makes medical students better communicators
  4. Protocol: Multisource feedback and work performance, a systematic review and meta-analysis
  5. The Enneagram: A systematic review of the literature and directions for future research (Hook et al., 2021)

EnneagramCheck is for self-reflection and education. It is not a medical or psychological tool, it is not for employment decisions, and it does not replace advice from a licensed professional.

Take the test

Your privacy choices

We use essential cookies to run the site. With your permission, we also use analytics to learn which pages help people. Optional cookies stay off until you turn them on, and we never sell your results. Read the privacy policy