A realistic New Year plan for each Enneagram type (not just resolutions)
Most resolutions fade by December. Try a light four-part plan, then nine small versions of it, one for each Enneagram type, built on what the studies show.
A realistic New Year plan is small enough to survive a bad week. It has a direction you move toward, one step you can repeat, one check-in, and a rule for changing the plan. Your Enneagram type can show where plans tend to slip, but it can't predict what you will do.
It is the second week of January. The gym bag is by the door, the planner is color-coded, and some part of you already knows how this goes. Most of us have been here before, and a lot of us have set the same resolution more than once.
This post is for that feeling. It starts with what studies show about why plans fade, then gives you a four-part plan and nine short versions of it, one per type. Those nine are reflection ideas, not research results, and the section on what the Enneagram can't do says why. If you want a wider look at goals and drive, the success guide is a good next stop.
Why do most resolutions fade?
Mostly because they start strong and have nothing holding them up later. In a large Swedish study of about 1,060 adults, people rated their own success with a resolution each month. Self-reported success slid from about 89% in January to about 55% in December. Those are self-ratings from people who chose to join, so read them as a rough picture, not a law.
Two other details from that study stand out:
- Move toward, don't just stop. Resolutions framed as something to move toward were rated as more successful than ones framed as stopping something: 58.9% against 47.1%. The effect was small, but the direction is easy to use. "Cook more at home" is a direction. "Stop ordering takeout" is a ban.
- Vague goals are common. In a smaller study of 182 adults, about 65% of resolutions were general or abstract, such as "get fit," and about half repeated a resolution from a past year. Many people stopped within weeks.
None of this means you lack willpower. A resolution on its own is just a weak tool.
Can a plan be too tight?
Yes, and the result is a bit surprising. In the Swedish study, one group got extra structure: a SMART-goal format, six interim goals, and several motivation emails. That group did not do better than people who got no support at all. The group that did best had something lighter: a named support person and monthly check-ins. The authors suggest that very specific, time-framed goals may give people more chances to feel they have failed.
An older pair of studies points the same way for one kind of person. Detailed when-and-where plans backfired on goal progress for people high in socially prescribed perfectionism, meaning the feeling that other people expect you to be flawless.
So the lesson isn't "plan less." It's "plan lighter, and expect to edit." A plan that you are afraid to break tends to get dropped whole.
What reason will carry you?
The reason behind a resolution seems to matter as much as the resolution. In a study of 297 adults with exercise resolutions, doing it for enjoyment or personal meaning predicted sticking with it at every check. Pressure and obligation did not help, and they were linked to lower wellbeing early on. In the same research, being able to adjust a goal when obstacles showed up went with better wellbeing, though it did not guarantee people kept going.
Dropout was high in these smaller studies, and everything was self-reported. Still, it matches what most of us have seen: "I should" runs out of fuel faster than "I like this."
The four-part plan
Here is the plan, before we get to your type:
- Direction. One thing you want to move toward, said in positive terms.
- One small step. The smallest action you could repeat, even in a busy week.
- One check-in. A person or a date, so the plan isn't only in your head.
- An adjust rule. What you will change at the first stumble, decided in advance.
The adjust rule is the part most plans skip. Write it as "If I miss twice, I will…" and you've turned a failure into a step in the plan.
Nine plans, one for each type
Read all nine if you like. Your type is a starting guess, and the year-end reflection questions can help you check it against your own year. These plans are ideas to try, not findings. No study has tested them.
Type 1, the Principled
A tendency to watch: setting a standard so high that one slip feels like the whole plan failed.
Direction: build a routine that feels steady, not flawless. Small step: one repeatable action, done "well enough." Check-in: a friend who is allowed to say "that's good enough." Adjust rule: if you miss a day, count the next day as day one of the same streak, not a restart.
Type 2, the Nurturer
A tendency to watch: putting everyone else's goals first until your own plan has no room left.
Direction: make space for one thing that is only yours. Small step: put one appointment with yourself on the calendar. Check-in: someone who asks about you first. Adjust rule: if you cancel for someone else twice, move the slot instead of dropping it.
Type 3, the Driver
A tendency to watch: turning the plan into a scoreboard, and valuing the result over whether you like the thing. Type 3, the Driver, often knows the pull to optimize.
Direction: pick something that matters to you even if nobody sees it. Small step: one action with no tracking. Check-in: a person who asks how it felt, not how it scored. Adjust rule: if you catch yourself polishing the numbers, drop one metric.
Type 4, the Original
A tendency to watch: waiting for the right mood, or dropping a plan that starts to feel ordinary.
Direction: shape the plan to feel like yours. Small step: do one repeat action on a day you don't feel inspired. Check-in: a note to yourself at the end of each week. Adjust rule: if the plan feels flat, change the style, not the step.
Type 5, the Scholar
A tendency to watch: researching the perfect system and never starting it.
Direction: learn by doing something small. Small step: act before you've finished reading. Check-in: one person who will see what you actually did. Adjust rule: if you are on your third source and have done nothing, do the step first.
Type 6, the Steadfast
A tendency to watch: scanning for what could go wrong, then staying put to be safe.
Direction: move toward something steady and known. Small step: a first step small enough to feel safe. Check-in: a trusted person you can think out loud with. Adjust rule: write down your backup plan up front, so a setback is already covered.
Type 7, the Optimist
A tendency to watch: starting with joy and drifting to the next bright idea.
Direction: pick one thing and keep it fun. Small step: a repeat action you can enjoy, with one variation allowed. Check-in: a friend who'll cheer the follow-through, not just the idea. Adjust rule: before adding a new goal, finish or retire an old one.
Type 8, the Powerhouse
A tendency to watch: going all in, then pushing past tiredness or other people's limits.
Direction: aim your strength at one thing. Small step: a steady action, not a sprint. Check-in: someone who tells you straight when you're overdoing it. Adjust rule: if you push three days in a row, schedule a lighter day.
Type 9, the Harmonizer
A tendency to watch: letting the plan slide to keep the peace or avoid friction. For Type 9, the Harmonizer, a plan often fades quietly, not dramatically.
Direction: name what you want, even if it's modest. Small step: attach one action to something you already do daily. Check-in: a regular date with someone who asks what you want. Adjust rule: if you notice you've said "I don't mind" three times, say what you do want.
What can the Enneagram actually do here?
Less than confident summaries suggest. A systematic review of Enneagram research found mixed evidence overall and little research on ideas such as wings and movement between types. Small studies have linked types to health habits, but those effects are modest and early. So treat your type as a lens for noticing your own patterns, and trust your own year over any label.
If you aren't sure of your type yet, take the test to find your core type.
Putting it to work
Pick one of the plans above and write it on a single line: direction, step, check-in, adjust rule. Tell the person you chose. Then look at it on the date you set, and change whatever isn't working.
If stress has been hurting your sleep or work for weeks, talk to a doctor or a licensed counselor. A plan helps with habits, but it is not a replacement for that kind of support.
Frequently asked questions
How do I make a realistic New Year plan?
Pick one direction to move toward, one small step you can repeat, one person or date to check in with, and a rule for changing the plan when it stops fitting. Keep it light, and write the whole plan on one line.
Does my Enneagram type decide what plan I should make?
No. The type plans here are reflection ideas, not research findings. Studies of the Enneagram show mixed support overall, so use your type to notice your usual pattern, then edit the plan until it fits your real life.
What if I already broke my resolution by February?
That is common. In one large study, self-reported success fell month by month, from about 89% in January to about 55% in December. Adjust the plan and keep going rather than starting over with guilt.
Is it better to set a specific goal or a general one?
The evidence is mixed. Many resolutions are vague, which makes them hard to check, but heavy detail can add pressure. One clear step with a loose finish line is a fair middle ground.
Sources
- A large-scale experiment on New Year's resolutions: Approach-oriented goals are more successful than avoidance-oriented goals (Oscarsson et al., PLoS ONE, 2020)
- Self-Regulatory Goal Motivational Processes in Sustained New Year Resolution Pursuit and Mental Wellbeing (2021)
- Adaptive Goal Processes and Underlying Motives That Sustain Mental Wellbeing and New Year Exercise Resolutions (2023)
- Implementation Intentions, Perfectionism, and Goal Progress (Powers, Koestner and Topciu, 2005)
- The Enneagram: A systematic review of the literature and directions for future research (Hook et al., 2021)